Miyazaki; or, An apology to my siblings.

February 22, 2009

My younger brother and sister are much smarter than I am. They’ve always been, to my mind at any rate, more comfortable being themselves and experiencing new things than I am (and I’m pretty comfortable). Some of the things they discovered far before I did were movies by Hayao Miyazaki – for my purposes, namely Spirited Away and Howl’s Moving Castle.

Disney is responsible for the North American release of both these films, and so they’re available on one disc (each) with both Japanese + subtitles and dubbed.  Take my word for it – at least for your first viewing, watch with subtitles. Especially in Spirited Away, the English translation has robbed the movie of some of its poetry.  F’r’instance, as the young girl leaves her home with her family at the beginning of the story, in the Japanese she says she was given “farewell flowers”. The dubbed version sounds obnoxious and uses less beautiful language (Howl’s Moving Castle has remedied this, somewhat).

Spirited Away uses a fairy tale story to represent the rites of passage of this young girl…but it’s more than that. There’s a wonder in the movie’s depiction of things, including “real life” details: the family drives an Audi, trying to strike a balance between amusement and economy, and work. Unlike a fairy tale, work is her way out of the fairy tale, not the other way around. It’s about kindness, and selflessness, and, what I like best – about there being another world just beyond, there for whenever you need it. In that sense, it reminded me of a fine tradition of stories like Alice in Wonderland, The Wizard of Oz (although in that novel, the other world isn’t a dream at all), or a movie like Labyrinth.

Which is sort of convenient, because the first time we’re introduced to Howl, of Howl’s Moving Castle, all I could think of was how much he looks like David Bowie.  The story is more straightforward, perhaps, than that of Spirited Away: still about romance, kindness, personal responsibility. Sophie is one of the most beautiful, strong female characters I’ve seen in a long time, especially in movies.

But I think one of the best elements of both films is that, while there’s an amazing attention to detail in execution, the stories don’t feel the need to strain themselves with explication. Because they’re so well made, we’re expected to, at some point, begin taking them for their own sake, and not look for too much narrative consistency, or really for anything other than the joy and wonder of what’s onscreen.

3 Responses to “Miyazaki; or, An apology to my siblings.”

  1. kiirstin said

    Those two movies are my all-time favourites. I don’t buy a lot of movies, and I’m actually a pretty bad slacker about watching movies. But I’ve lost track of the number of times I’ve seen both of these.

    I agree, the dubbing is pretty bad — although not as bad as it could be, given some of the dubbing I’ve witnessed on films coming out of Japan. The subtitles are far better. And they’re less confusing, too.

    I love both movies as much for the beauty of the animation and art, as for the stories themselves. The stories are wonderful and charming, and the characters are fresh and interesting. But the visual beauty of both films sets them far and above any other animated film I’ve seen.

    You might want to try Kiki’s Flying Delivery Service, or My Neighbour Totoro next. I love Totoro, too… it’s not action-packed, but it’s very sweet.

  2. daughterofben said

    He also has a new one coming out, done in watercolours. It should be very pretty.

  3. c joy said

    I’m glad you liked Howl’s Moving Castle (Billy Crystal? :D) although unfortunately I will never be able to watch it again without thinking ‘David Bowie’. Oh well :3

    For a different sort of anime, try any of Satoshi Kon’s movies; Tokyo Godfathers is one that got me very engaged emotionally, which is something that, while Miyazaki’s movies are beautiful and charming, I rarely find myself emotionally attracted to his characters. Even in Princess Mononoke, while noble and strong, it’s a little hard to really feel for San and Ashitaka because we can’t really relate.

    Incidentally, I’d love a copy of the Mononoke soundtrack for my birthday, if you ever see it anywhere.

    Other Satoshi Kon movies I can recommend are Millenium Actress, about a woman recounting her life’s experiences as a movie star; again with the emotional journey and coming-of-age themes.

    If you find Paprika, another Kon film, I would recommend that you don’t watch it just yet. I had to have bits of it explained to me. A friend of mine who is a big fan of anime called it “a mind-fuck”. If you’re not a bit crazy, Paprika may not be right for you.

    Love ❤

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: